Excellent value for the quality you get.
Winner
The Jean Paul AS-400SP is a silver-plated alto saxophone designed with beginners in mind. It features a durable combination of silver and brass materials, giving it a classic look and reliable build quality. The instrument plays in B flat, which is standard for alto saxophones, making it suitable for most beginner lessons and band settings. It comes with a Bari mouthpiece and a Rico H ligature and cap, which are decent components for new players starting out, although more experienced players might eventually want to upgrade these parts for better sound quality.
The saxophone includes a professional carrying case, a quality neck strap, and a care kit, which add value and make it easier to maintain the instrument. Weighing about 12 pounds, it is somewhat on the heavier side for a student model, which might be a consideration for younger players regarding comfort during extended practice. The key mechanism and ergonomics are generally well-regarded, offering smooth playability for beginners. The high customer rating (4.6 out of 5) suggests most users find it reliable and good for learning.
Since it is made in China, some may be concerned about long-term durability compared to higher-end brands. This saxophone represents a solid choice for someone starting to learn, providing good accessories and build quality at an affordable price, but it might feel a bit heavy and could require mouthpiece upgrades as a player advances.
The Mendini By Cecilio Eb Alto Saxophone is a versatile instrument suitable for both beginners and advanced players, making it great for adults and children alike. It features a sleek, lacquered design with a high F# key, adding both style and sound quality. The craftsmanship is commendable with a large bore, ribbed construction, quality leather pads, and metal tone boosters, ensuring durability and good sound projection.
The contoured keys with faux mother of pearl inlays add a touch of elegance and comfort during play. This saxophone comes as a complete set including a durable hard-shell case, mouthpiece, tuner, neck strap, 10 reeds, cleaning cloth, rod, and a pair of gloves, providing everything needed to start playing right away. Additionally, the chromatic tuner with metronome helps with tuning and practice, although it requires 2 AAA batteries which are not included.
The instrument is lightweight and ergonomically designed, making it easy to handle during extended play sessions. However, some users might find the need to replace the mouthpiece and reeds for higher quality options as they advance in their skills. Despite its lightweight, the saxophone dimensions are quite standard, ensuring a comfortable playing experience. This saxophone is a great option for those looking to start or continue their musical journey on a reliable and well-equipped instrument.
The Yamaha YAS-280 Alto Saxophone is a solid choice for beginners, designed to provide an enjoyable and accessible entry into the world of saxophone playing. One of its key strengths is its construction; made by Yamaha, a reputable brand in musical instruments, it features a durable gold lacquer finish that not only looks great but also helps resist wear. The inclusion of high F# and front F auxiliary keys is a significant advantage, allowing for more playing versatility as a student progresses in skill. Additionally, the instrument is relatively lightweight at 13.23 pounds, which can make it easier for younger or less experienced players to handle.
In terms of playability, the YAS-280 is designed with ergonomics in mind, making it comfortable for extended practice sessions. The key mechanism is smooth, which is a big plus for beginners learning finger placements and transitioning between notes. The saxophone comes complete with a case, adding value by providing protection for this investment.
The Yamaha YAS-280 is a great starter saxophone that balances quality and ease of use well, making it particularly suitable for new players eager to learn.