
Quality and price are both spot on.

Winner
The Kwikset Halo Select Plus is a modern smart lock designed for users who want convenient and secure keyless home access. It offers multiple ways to unlock your door, including a touchscreen keypad, app control, voice commands, and a unique tap-to-unlock feature using Apple Home Keys with NFC technology. This makes it especially handy for iPhone or Apple Watch users who want quick entry without fumbling for keys.
The lock supports Wi-Fi and Matter protocols, allowing smooth integration with popular smart home platforms like Apple HomeKit, Amazon Alexa, Google Home, and SmartThings. You can remotely lock or unlock your door, share access codes with guests, and receive alerts about door status or possible intrusions, adding peace of mind. The built-in auto-lock and geofencing features enable the lock to secure your door automatically or unlock it as you approach, enhancing convenience. Battery life relies on included alkaline batteries, which is standard but means you need to monitor for replacements to avoid lockouts.
The lock is solidly built with metal and includes an alarm for extra security, though some users might find the touchscreen sensitive or tricky in bright sunlight. The ability to share up to 250 access codes is generous compared to many locks, making it suitable for households with frequent visitors or property managers. The Halo Select Plus is well suited for homeowners who want a feature-rich, user-friendly smart lock with strong Apple ecosystem support and flexible access options, while considering battery upkeep and touchscreen sensitivity.
The Kwikset SmartCode 916 is a polished chrome smart lock designed for keyless entry with a touchscreen keypad, making it easy and quiet to lock and unlock your door. It supports up to 30 unique user codes, which is great for giving access to family members, friends, or service providers without sharing physical keys. The lock includes a SmartKey Re-Key feature, enhancing security by allowing you to quickly rekey the lock if needed. It connects through Z-Wave technology, so to control it remotely or integrate it with your smart home system, a compatible smart hub is required. This lock works with popular platforms like Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Ring, and SmartThings, enabling voice control and remote management once set up. An auto-lock feature can be programmed to secure your door about 30 seconds after closing, adding convenience and peace of mind.
Battery life is about 12 months using four AA batteries, which are included, so you won’t need frequent replacements. Installation is straightforward and can be done with a screwdriver, fitting standard door thicknesses. On the downside, needing a separate Z-Wave hub might be inconvenient if you don't already have a smart home system in place. Also, while the keypad is illuminated and user-friendly, it requires manual code entry, which some might find slower compared to fully keyless or biometric options. The product has a solid mechanical lifetime warranty and a one-year electronics warranty, which shows Kwikset's confidence in its durability.
This smart lock is a practical choice for those looking to upgrade their front door with reliable keyless access and smart home compatibility, especially if they already use Z-Wave-based systems. It balances security and convenience, though it does rely on a hub and manual code input for smart features.
The Kwikset Powerbolt 250 is a smart lock designed to enhance convenience and security for homeowners. One of its primary strengths is the keyless entry feature, which allows users to lock and unlock their doors without needing physical keys, making it perfect for those who prefer modern convenience. The customizable user codes, including 25 user codes and 5 one-time codes, offer flexibility for different entry needs, whether it's for family members, visitors, or service providers.
The auto-lock feature is another notable strength, providing peace of mind by automatically securing the door after a set period, which is adjustable from 30 seconds to 10 minutes. Additionally, the intrusion alert feature enhances security by sounding an alarm and disabling the keypad after three incorrect code attempts, deterring potential tampering. The lock's easy low light code entry, with bright LED lights illuminating the keypad, is particularly useful for nighttime access. The vacation mode adds an extra layer of security by disabling the keypad when you're away from home for an extended period. SmartKey Security technology allows users to re-key the lock themselves, adding an extra level of protection against advanced break-in techniques.
The battery life of at least 12 months minimizes the hassle of frequent replacements, although it's important to note that the required AA batteries are not included. Installation is straightforward with just a screwdriver, and the BILT app provides interactive instructions for a smooth setup. However, the lack of integration with smart home systems might be a downside for users looking to connect the lock with other smart devices in their home. The Kwikset Powerbolt 250 is well-suited for those prioritizing ease of use, security, and straightforward installation, but it may not fully meet the needs of those seeking advanced connectivity options.